Call us: +1-415-738-4000

Securing Terracotta Clusters

Introduction

Terracotta clusters can be secured using authentication, authorization, and encryption. Built-in authentication and authorization is available, as is support for external directory services. In addition, certificate-based Secure Sockets Layer (SSL) encryption can be used to secure communications between nodes.

Security in a Terracotta cluster includes both server-server connections and client-server connections. Note that all connections in a secured cluster must be secure; no insecure connections are allowed, and therefore security must be enabled globally in the cluster, including in the Terracotta Management Server. It is not possible to enable security for certain nodes only.

Overview

Security is set up using Terracotta configuration, tools provided in the Terracotta kit, standard Java tools, and public key infrastructure (via standard digital X.509 digital certificates).

Each Terracotta server utilizes the following types of files to implement security:

  • Java keystore – Contains the server's private key and public-key certificate. Protected by a keystore/certificate-entry password.
  • Truststore – A keystore file containing only the certificates' public keys. Needed only if using self-signed certificates, not a Certificate Authority (CA).
  • Keychain – Stores passwords, including to the server's keystore and to entries in these other files. The tools for creating and managing the Terracotta keychain file are provided with the Terracotta kit.
  • Authorization – A .ini file with password-protected user accounts and their roles for servers and clients that connect to the server.
    Microsoft Active Directory and standard LDAP authentication/authorization are available options.
TIP: Secure cacerts File
The standard Java cacerts file, located in ${JAVA_HOME}java.home/lib/security by default, is a system-wide repository for CA root certificates included with the JDK. These certificates can play a part in certificate chains. Java documentation recommends that the cacerts file be protected by changing its default password and file permissions.

Each Terracotta client also has a keychain file that stores the password it uses to authenticate with the server.

All files are read on startup. Changes made to the files after startup cannot be read unless the cluster is restarted.

Process Diagram

The following diagram illustrates the flow of security information—and that information's origin in terms of the files described above—during initial cluster connections:

IMAGE: Security flow (obfuscation)

From a Terracotta server's point of view, security checks take place at the time a connection is made with another node on the cluster:

  1. After startup, servers can begin to make connection requests to servers named in configuration.
  2. A connection request from server2 initiates the process of establishing a secure connection using SSL.
  3. Server1 authenticates server2 using stored credentials. Credentials are also associated with a role that authorizes server2. The process is symmetrical: server2 authenticates and authorizes server1.
  4. A connection request from a Terracotta client initiates the process of establishing a secure connection using SSL.
  5. Server1 authenticates and authorizes the client using stored credentials and associated roles. Because clients may be communicating with any active server in the cluster during their lifetimes, the client must be able to authenticate with any active server. Clients should be able to authenticate against all servers in the cluster, since active servers may fail over to mirror servers.

From a Terracotta client's point of view, security checks occur at the time the client attempts to connect to an active server in the cluster:

  1. The client uses a server URI that includes the client username.

    A typical (non-secure) URI is <server-address>:<port>. A URI that initiates a secure connection takes the form <client-username>@<server-address>:<port>.

  2. A secure connection using SSL is established with the server.

  3. The client sends a password fetched from a local keychain file. The password is associated with the client username.

Configuration Example

The following configuration snippet is an example of how security could be set up for the servers in the illustration above:

<tc:tc-config xmlns:tc="http://www.terracotta.org/config">
...
  <servers secure="true"> 
    <server host="172.16.254.1" name="server1">
    ...
      <security>
        <ssl>
          <certificate>jks:server1alias@/the/path/keystore-file.jks</certificate>
        </ssl>
        <keychain>
          <url>file:///%(user.dir)/server1keychain.tkc</url>
        </keychain>
        <auth>
          <realm>com.tc.net.core.security.ShiroIniRealm</realm>
          <url>file:///%(user.dir)/my_auth.ini</url>
          <user>server1username</user>
        </auth>
      </security>
   ...
   </server>
    <server host="172.16.254.2" name="server2">
    ...
      <security>
        <ssl>
          <certificate>jks:server2alias@/the/path/keystore-file.jks</certificate>
        </ssl>
        <keychain>
          <url>file:///%(user.dir)/server2keychain.tkc</url>
        </keychain>
        <auth>
          <realm>com.tc.net.core.security.ShiroIniRealm</realm>
          <url>file:///%(user.dir)/my_auth.ini</url>
          <user>server2username</user>
        </auth>
      </security>
   ...
   </server>
   ...
 </servers>
...
</tc:tc-config>

See the configuration section below for more information on the configuration elements in the example.

Setting Up Server Security

To set up security on a Terracotta server, follow the steps in each of these procedures:

NOTE: Script names in the examples given below are for *NIX systems. Equivalent scripts are available for Microsoft Windows in the same locations. Simply substitute the .bat extension for the .sh extension shown and convert path delimiters as appropriate.

Create the Server Certificate and Add It to the Keystore

Each Terracotta server must have a keystore file containing a digital certificate and the associated private key. This document assumes that you will use self-signed certificates. Self-signed certificates do not carry a digital signature from an official CA.

IMPORTANT SECURITY CONSIDERATION!: Self-signed certificates might be less safe than CA-signed certificates because they lack third-party identity verification and do not carry a digital signature from an official CA. Your organization might already have policies and procedures in place regarding the generation and use of digital certificates and certificate chains, including the use of certificates signed by a Certificate Authority (CA). To follow your organization's policies and procedures regarding using digital certificates, you might need to adjust the procedures outlined in this document.

When used for a Terracotta server, the following conditions must be met for certificates and their keystores:

  • The keystore must be a Java keystore (JKS) compatible with JDK 1.6 or higher.
  • The certificate must be keyed with the alias named in the value of the <certificate> element of the server's configuration.
  • The Common Name (CN) field in the Distinguished Name must contain the hostname of the server, as configured in the server's configuration.
  • The password securing the certificate must match the keystore's main password. In other words, the store password and key passwords must be identical.
  • When using a self-signed certificate (not one signed by a trusted CA), create a custom truststore for storing public keys.
  • If security is not the most important consideration, you can set the following Java system properties as shown:
    • -Dtc.ssl.trustAllCerts=true (use any certificates)
    • -Dtc.ssl.disableHostnameVerifier=true (bypass hostname verification)

If you have a keystore in place, but the server certificate is not already stored in the keystore, you must import it into the keystore. If the keystore does not already exist, you must create it.

Creating Self-Signed Certificates Using Java Keytool

For testing purposes, or if you intend to use self-signed certificates, use the Java keytool command to create the public-private key pair. You also use this command to create keystores and truststores, but note that keytool refers to truststores as "keystores" since there is only a logical difference.

Specifying a Custom Truststore
Note that if you are not using cacerts, the default Java truststore, the custom truststore must be specified with the javax.net.ssl.trustStore system property. In this case, you can choose to reset the custom truststore's default password with javax.net.ssl.trustStorePassword.

The following could be used to create both public-private keys (including a certificate) and a keystore file for the server called "server1" in the configuration example above:

keytool -genkey -keystore keystore-file.jks -dname "CN=172.16.254.1, OU=Terracotta, O=SAG, L=San Francisco, S=California, C=US" -alias server1alias -storepass server1pass -keypass server1pass

Note that the values passed to -storepass and -keypass match. Also, the field designating the Common Name (CN) must match the server's hostname, which matches the value entered in the server's configuration. This hostname can be an IP address or a resolvable domain name. If the -dname option is left out, a series of identity prompts (distinguished-name fields based on the X.500 standard) will appear before the server's entry is created in the keystore. The CN prompt appears as shown:

What is your first and last name?
   [Unknown]:

There are a number of other keytool options to consider, including -keyalg (cryptographic algorithm; default is DSA) and -validity (number of days until the certificate expires; default is 90). These and other options are dependent on your environment and security requirements. See the JDK documentation for more information on using the keytool.

Create a keystore and entry on each Terracotta server.

Exporting and Importing Certificates

Each server should have a copy of each other server's public-key certificate in its truststore.

The following could be used to export the certificate of the server called "server1" in the configuration example above:

keytool -export -alias server1alias -keystore keystore-file.jks \
    -file server1SelfSignedCert.cert

This "cert" file can now be used to import server1's certificate into the truststore of every other server. For example, to create a truststore and import server1's certificate on server2, copy the cert file to the working directory on server2 and use the following command:

keytool -import -alias server1alias -file server1SelfSignedCert.cert \
    -keystore truststore.jks

After the password prompt, information about the certificate appears, and you are prompted to trust it. You must repeat this process until every server has a truststore containing the public-key certificate of every other server in the cluster.

TIP: Use a Single Truststore
Instead of recreating the truststore on every server, create a single truststore containing every server's public key, then copy that to every server. This same truststore can also be used for clients..

Set Up the Server Keychain

The keystore and each certificate entry are protected by passwords stored in the server keychain file. The location of the keychain file is specified in the value of the <url> element under the <keychain> element of the server's configuration file.

For example, with this server configuration, when the server starts up, the keychain file would be searched for in the user's (process owner's) home directory. In the configuration example, a keychain file called server1keychain.tkc is searched for when server1 is started.

The keychain file should have the following entries:

  • An entry for the local server's keystore entry.
  • An entry for every server that the local server will connect to.

Entries are created using the keychain script found in the Terracotta kit's tools/security/bin directory.

Creating an Entry for the Local Server

Create an entry for the local server's keystore password:

tools/security/bin/keychain.sh -O <keychain-file> <certificate-URI>

where <keychain-file> is the file named in the server configuration's <keychain>/<url> element (including correct path), and <certificate-URI> is the URI value in the server configuration's <ssl>/<certificate> element. Note: The <certificate-URI> must match the server configuration's <ssl>/<certificate> element exactly, including the path to the keystore.

By default, the keychain file stores passwords using an obfuscation scheme, requiring the use of -O (hyphen capital letter O) with the keychain script for any operation on the file. To switch a more secure encryption-based scheme, see Using Encrypted Keychains.

If the keychain file does not exist, add the -c option to create it:

tools/security/bin/keychain.sh -O -c <keychain-file> <certificate-URI>

You will be prompted to enter a password to associate with the URI. You must enter the same password used to secure the server's certificate in the keystore.

For example, to create an entry for server1 from the configuration example above, enter:

tools/security/bin/keychain.sh -O server1keychain.tkc jks:server1alias@/the/path/keystore-file.jks

Terracotta Management Console - Keychain Client
Enter the password you wish to associate with this URL:   server1pass
Confirm the password to associate with this URL:   server1pass
Password for jks:server1alias@/the/path/keystore-file.jks successfully stored

Creating Entries for Remote Servers

Entries for remote servers have the format tc://<user>@<host>:<group-port>. Note that the value of <user> is specified in each server configuration's <security>/<auth>/<user> and is not related to the user running as process owner. If a value for <security>/<auth>/<user> is not specified, the username "terracotta" is used by default.

For example, to create an entry for server2 in server1's keychain, use:

tools/security/bin/keychain.sh -O server1keychain.tkc tc://server2username@172.16.254.2:9530

If the keychain file does not exist, add the -c option:

tools/security/bin/keychain.sh -O -c server1keychain.tkc tc://server2username@172.16.254.2:9530

You will be prompted to enter a password to associate with the entry server2username@172.16.254.2:9530.

An entry for server1 must also be added to server2's keychain:

tools/security/bin/keychain.sh -O server2keychain.tkc tc://server1@172.16.254.1:9530

Set Up Authentication/Authorization

Servers and clients that connect to a secured server must have credentials (usernames/passwords) and roles (authorization) defined. This section discusses the provided authentication/authorization mechanism, based on using a .ini file. To use LDAP or Microsoft Active Directory instead, see the LDAP/AD setup page.

Authentication and authorization are set up using the usermanagement script, located in the Terracotta kit's tools/security/bin directory. This script also creates the .ini file that contains the required usernames and roles (associated passwords are stored in the keychain file).

All nodes in a secured Terracotta cluster must have an entry in the server's .ini file:

  • The local server itself
  • All other servers
  • All clients

Use the usermanagement script with the following format:

tools/security/bin/usermanagement.sh -c <file> <username> terracotta

where -c is required only if the file does not already exist. For servers, the <username> will be used as the value configured in <security>/<auth>/<user>. For clients, the username must match the one used to start the client.

Note: While the "terracotta" role is appropriate for Terracotta servers and clients, the "admin" role is necessary for performing system functions such as stopping servers. For more information about roles, refer to the User Roles section.

For example:

# Create the .ini file and add a server username and role.
tools/security/bin/usermanagement.sh -c my_auth.ini server1username terracotta

# Add another server.
tools/security/bin/usermanagement.sh my_auth.ini server2username terracotta

# Add a client.
tools/security/bin/usermanagement.sh my_auth.ini client1username terracotta

# Add a user with an "admin" (read/write) role.
tools/security/bin/usermanagement.sh my_auth.ini admin1username admin

# Add a user with a "terracotta" (read) role.
tools/security/bin/usermanagement.sh my_auth.ini console1username operator

The correct Shiro realm must be specified in the server configuration, along with the path to the .ini file:

...
<auth>
  <realm>com.tc.net.core.security.ShiroIniRealm</realm>
  <url>file:///%(user.dir)/my_auth.ini</url>
  <user>server1username</user>
</auth>
...

Configure Server Security

Security for the Terracotta Server Array is configured in the Terracotta configuration file (tc-config.xml by default). The following is an example security configuration:

<tc:tc-config xmlns:tc="http://www.terracotta.org/config">
...
  <servers secure="true"> 
    <server host="172.16.254.1" name="server1">
    ...
      <security>
        <ssl>
          <certificate>jks:server1alias@/the/path/keystore-file.jks</certificate>
        </ssl>
        <keychain>
          <url>file:///%(user.dir)/server1keychain.tkc</url>
        </keychain>
        <auth>
          <realm>com.tc.net.core.security.ShiroIniRealm</realm>
          <url>file:///%(user.dir)/my_auth.ini</url>
          <user>server1username</user>
        </auth>
      </security>
   ...
   </server>
   ...
 </servers>
...
</tc:tc-config>

Every server participating in an SSL-based secured cluster must have a <security> block wherein security-related information is encapsulated and defined. The keystore, keychain, and .ini files named in the configuration must be available to every server in the cluster. LDAP or Microsoft Active Directory can be configured in place of file-based authentication/authorization.

The following table defines selected security-related elements and attributes shown in the configuration example.

NameDefinitionNotes
secure Attribute in <servers> element. Enables SSL security for the cluster. DEFAULT: false. Enables/disables SSL-based security globally.
certificate Element specifying the location of the server's authentication certificate and its containing keystore file. The format for the certificate-keystore location is jks:alias@/path/to/keystore. "alias" must match the value used to key the certificate in the keystore file. Only the JKS type of keystore is supported.
url The URI for the keychain file (when under <keychain>) or for the authentication/authorization mechanism (when under <auth>). These URIs are passed to the keychain or realm class to specify the keychain file or authentication/authorization source, respectively. These files are created and managed with the keychain and usermanagement scripts. If using Microsoft Active Directory or LDAP, an LDAP or LDAPS connection is specified. The configured URL for locating the keychain file can be overridenn with the property com.tc.security.keychain.url.
realm The Shiro security realm that determines the type of authentication/authorization scheme being used: file-based (.ini), Microsoft Active Directory, or standard LDAP. This element's value is specified in the section covering the setup for the chosen authentication/authorization scheme.
user The username that represents this server and is authenticated by other servers. This name is part of the server's credentials. Default username is "terracotta"

Enabling SSL on Terracotta Clients

Terracotta clients do not require any specific configuration to enable SSL connections to a Terracotta Server Array.

NOTE: Script names in the examples given below are for *NIX systems. Equivalent scripts are available for Microsoft Windows in the same locations. Simply substitute the .bat extension for the .sh extension shown and convert path delimiters as appropriate.

To enable SSL security on the client, ensure the following:

  • Prepend the client username to the address used by the client to connect to the cluster.

    This should be the username that will be authenticated followed by an "at" sign ("@") and the address of an active server running in secure mode. The format is <client-username>@<host>:<tsa-port>. Prepending the username automatically causes the client to initiate an SSL connection.

    If the client has username client1, for example, and attempts to connect to the server in the configuration example, the address would be:

    client1@172.16.254.1:9510
    

    This URI replaces the address <host>:<tsa-port> used to start clients in non-SSL clusters.

  • The client username and its corresponding password must match those in the server's .ini file or credentials in LDAP or Active Directory. The username is included in the URI, but the password must come from a local keychain entry that you create.

    The client credentials must be associated with the role "terracotta" or "admin".

  • If Terracotta servers are using self-signed certificates (not certificates signed by a well-known CA), then you must specify a truststore for the client which contains the public key of every server in the cluster.

Create a Keychain Entry

The Terracotta client should have a keychain file with an entry for every Terracotta server in the cluster. The format for the entry uses the "tc" scheme:

tc://<client-username>@<host>:<tsa-port>

An entry for the server in the example configuration should look like the following:

tc://client1@172.16.254.1:9510

Use the keychain script in the Terracotta kit to add the entry:

tools/security/bin/keychain.sh -O clientKeychainFile tc://client1@172.16.254.1:9510

By default, the keychain file stores passwords using an obfuscation scheme, requiring the use of -O (hyphen capital letter O) with the keychain script for any operation on the file. To switch a more secure encryption-based scheme, see this page.

If the keychain file does not already exist, use the -c flag to create it:

tools/security/bin/keychain.sh -O -c clientKeychainFile tc://client1@172.16.254.1:9510

You will be prompted to enter a client password to associate with the URI.

This entry in the client's keychain file serves as the key for the client's password, and will be provided to the server along with the client username ("client1" in the example). These credentials must match those in the server's .ini file or LDAP or Active Directory credentials.

The Terracotta client searches for the keychain file in the following locations:

  • %(user.home)/.tc/mgmt/keychain
  • %(user.dir)/keychain.tkc
  • The path specified by the system property com.tc.security.keychain.url

Example Using the Keychain Script

When you run the keychain script, the following prompt should appear:

Terracotta Management Console - Keychain Client
KeyChain file successfully created in clientKeychainFile
Enter the password you wish to associate with this URL: 
Password for tc://client1@172.16.254.1:9510 successfully stored

Note that the script does not verify the credentials or the server address.

Using a Client Truststore

If Terracotta servers are using self-signed certificates (not certificates signed by a well-known CA), create a truststore on the client and import each server's public-key certificate into that truststore.

If you have already created a truststore for a server in the TSA, you can copy that file to each client after first importing that server's public-key certificate into the copy.

For the client to find the truststore, you must set the Java system property javax.net.ssl.trustStore to the location of the truststore file. In this case, note the existing secrets for opening the truststore and accessing each certificate.

TIP: Changing the Truststore Password
To change the existing truststore master password, use the Java system property javax.net.ssl.trustStorePassword.

Security With the Terracotta Management Server

Additional configuration is required for using a secured TSA with the Terracotta Management Server (TMS):

Configuring Identity Assertion

Add the following to each server's <security> block:

<security>
...
  <management>
    <ia> https://my-tms.mydomain.com:9443/tmc/api/assertIdentity</ia>
    <timeout>10000</timeout>
    <hostname>my-l2.mydomain.com</ hostname >
  </management> 
</security>

where:

  • <timeout> is the the timeout value (in milliseconds) for connections from the server to the TMS.
  • <ia> is the HTTPS (or HTTP) URL with the domain of the TMS, followed by the port 9443 and the path /tmc/api/assertIdentity.

    If using HTTPS (recommended), export a public key from the TMS and import it into the server's truststore. You must also export a public key from the server and import it into the TMS's truststore, or copy the server's truststore (including the local server's public key) to the TMS.

  • <management><hostname> is used only if the DNS hostname of the server does not match server hostname used in its certificate. If there is a mismatch, enter the DNS address of the server here.

You must export a public key from the TMS

JMX Authentication Using the Keychain

The following is required for server-to-client REST-agent authorization to succeed. Every node in the cluster must have the following entry in its keychain, all locked with the identical secret:

jmx:net.sf.ehcache:type=RepositoryService

In addition, server-server REST-agent communication must also be authorized using a keychain entry with the following format:

jmx://<user>@<host>:<group-port>

Note that the value of <user> is specified in each server configuration's <security>/<auth>/<user> and is not related to the user running as process owner.

For example, to create an entry for server2 in server1's keychain, use:

tools/security/bin/keychain.sh -O server1keychain.tkc jmx://server2username@172.16.254.2:9530

Each server must have an entry for itself and one for each other server in the TSA.

Setting Up Security on the TMS

An unsecured TMS cannot connect to a secured TSA. See this page to learn how to set up security on the TMS.

Restricting Clients to Specified Servers (Optional)

By default, clients are not restricted to authenticate a specific set of servers when responding to REST requests. However, it is possible to explicitly list the servers that a client may respond to by using the <managementRESTService> element's securityServiceLocation attribute in the Ehcache configuration.

When this attribute is empty (or missing), no such restriction exists and the client will authenticate against any server in the cluster that meets the established security requirements. This is the recommended setting, as SSL connections and the authentication/authorization mechanism provide sufficient security.

In the case where an extra layer of security is required for the client's REST service, you can configure a list of allowed servers as follows:

<managementRESTService ... 
  securityServiceLocation=" https://my-l2-node1/tmc/api/assertIdentity ,  
     https://my-l2-node2/tmc/api/assertIdentity "> 

where my-l2-node1 and my-l2-node2 are the servers' hostnames. Note, however, that any of the servers in a client's cluster can forward a REST request to that client at any time, and so all servers should be listed if this feature is used.

Running a Secured Server

Start a server in a secure Terracotta cluster using the start-tc-server script as usual. If you are using encrypted keychains, a master password must be entered at the command line during server startup (or set the server to automatically fetch the password).

Confirm Security Enabled

You can confirm that a server in a number of ways:

  • Look for the startup message Security enabled, turning on SSL.
  • Search for log messages containing "SSL keystore", "HTTPS Authentication enabled", and "Security enabled, turning on SSL".
  • Attempt to make JMX connections to the server—these should fail.

Stopping a Secured Server

Stop a server in a secure Terracotta cluster using the stop-tc-server script with the following arguments:

  • -f <tc-config-file> — A valid path to the self-signed certificate must have been specified in the server's configuration file.
  • -u <username> — The user specified must have the "admin" role.
  • -w <password>

For more information about the stop script, refer to Start and Stop Server Scripts.

Troubleshooting

You may encounter any of the following errors at startup:

TCRuntimeException: ... Wrong secret provided ?

The following error indicates that the keychain file uses the default obfuscation scheme, but that the -O flag was not used with the keychain script:

com.tc.exception.TCRuntimeException: com.terracotta.management.keychain.crypto.SecretMismatchException: Wrong secret provided ?

Be sure to use the -O flag whenever using the keychain script.

No Configured SSL certificate

The following error indicates that no SSL certificate was found for the server named "myServer":

Fatal Terracotta startup exception:


*********************************************************************
Security is enabled but server myServer has no configured SSL certificate.
*********************************************************************

Check that the expected SSL certificate was created for myServer and stored at the configured location.

IllegalStateException: Invalid cluster security configuration

These types of errors typically occur when the security section in the Terracotta configuration file is not set up properly. However, this type of error can also indicate problems elsewhere in the security setup. For example, an error similar to the following can occur:

java.lang.IllegalStateException: Invalid cluster security configuration. Unable to find connection credentials to server myOtherServer

This error indicates that credentials cannot be found for the server named "myOtherServer". These credentials may be missing from or do not exist in the configured authentication source.

RuntimeException: Couldn't access a Console instance to fetch the password from!

This results from using "nohup" during startup. The startup process requires a console for reading password entry. In fact, you cannot run the startup process in the background if it requires manual password entry. See this section for information on how to avoid having to manually enter the master keychain password.

TCRuntimeException: Couldn't create KeyChain instance ...

The keychain file specified in the Terracotta configuration cannot be found. Check for the existence of the file at the location specified in <keychain>/<url> or the property com.tc.security.keychain.url.

RuntimeException: Couldn't read from file ...

This error appears just after an incorrect password is entered for an encrypted keychain file.

RuntimeException: No password available in keyChain for ...

This error appears if no keychain password entry is found for the server's certificate. You must explicitly store the certificate password in the keychain file.

This error could also appear if the resolved hostname or IP address is different from the one in the keychain entry:

  • tc://terracotta@localhost:9530 is the entry, but when the server configuration is read then localhost is resolved to an IP address. The entry searched for becomes tc://terracotta@<a.certain.ip.address>:9530.

  • tc://terracotta@<a.certain.ip.address>:9530 is the entry, but when the server configuration is read then <a.certain.ip.address> is resolved to a host name. The entry searched for becomes tc://terracotta@my.host.com:9530.

Two Active Servers (Split Brain)

Instead of an active-mirror 2-server stripe, both servers assert active status after being started. This error can be caused by the failure of the SSL handshake. An entry similar to the following may appear in the server log:

2013-05-17 12:10:24,805 [L2_L2:TCWorkerComm # 1_W] ERROR com.tc.net.core.TCConnection - SSL handshake error: unable to find valid certification path to requested target, closing connection. 

For each server, ensure that all keychain entries are accurate, and that the required certificates are available from the appropriate truststores.

No Messages Indicating Security Enabled

If servers start with no errors, but there are no messages indicating that security is enabled, ensure that the <servers> element contains secure="true".